Re birth or re incarnation....

[afzaluddin]

ualikum 2 all.

I have a very intresting topic to discuss.........

i think we all have heard alot of times about rebirth.....

many of dem say tat this person has born again or (punarjanam) of a person
how can dis be posible.

So please let me know in islamic point of view about this topic .....

i hope you have understand my question?

[_knownothing_]

walikumsalaam brother
i heard about this only form hindus
in Muslim there is no such concept

[afzaluddin]

^ya i too heard dis from hindus...... but wat make dem believe tat i cant understand....
and not only hindus christians also believe in tat

[_knownothing_]

but this think never happened in reality

when they get married they always say hamara 7 janmo ka bandan hahi
but on the other hand they don't believe on the day of judgement i think

[AHB]

walikumsalaam brother
i heard about this only form hindus
in Muslim there is no such concept

[Altaf Sultani]

ualikum 2 all.

I have a very intresting topic to discuss.........

i think we all have heard alot of times about rebirth.....

many of dem say tat this person has born again or (punarjanam) of a person
how can dis be posible.

So please let me know in islamic point of view about this topic .....

i hope you have understand my question?

hindus believe but its not accepted in their veda's

" Beyond the three skies let him go,whence he shall NEVER COME AGAIN in all years to be long as the sun is in heaven."--[Arthava veda,6:75:3]

[Altaf Sultani]

Rig Veda confirms that the Creator creates all things of this world and the next , at a certain time :

"The father of the eye, the wise in spirit, created both these worlds."--[Rig veda,10:82:2]

[Altaf Sultani]

As per rebirth theory based on Manu's teachings, a person who commits adultery with the wife of another, or causes death of virtuous people,he gets the BODY OF A TREE, on his rebirth.

This is just baseless since a tree can contain several souls if propagated by cutting its branches and growing them separately.Each branch will become another tree.

[Altaf Sultani]

Even Bhagwat Geeta informs of Shri Krishna, the 8th avatar of Vishnu as saying. " Thinking on that, merged in that, solely devoted to that THEY GO WHENCE THERE IS NO RETURN, their signs dispelled by wisdom."--[Bhagwat Geeta,5:17]

[Altaf Sultani]

The 9th avatar of Vishnu was Buddha who said, " There is no evidence of an immutable ego-being, which remaineth and migrates from body to body."--[The Gospel of Buddha by Carus,p-23]

[Altaf Sultani]

"Gautama [Buddha] did not teach the transmigration of souls."--[Hibbert lecture by Rhys Davids, 1880, p-91]

"His [Budhha's] doctrine was not metempsycosis."--[Chiristianity & Buddhism by Sterling Berry,p-75]

[Altaf Sultani]

In JAINISM also, the rebirth theory is not acceptable;


"We will now adopt the law, after the adoption of which WE WILL NOT BE BORN AGAIN."--[Gyan Sutra, part II s.b.e.XIV,p-65]

[Altaf Sultani]

The Sikh Guru Nanak Sahib also discarded this theory;

" The Lord has become mercyful, COMING AND GOING HAS STOPPED."--[Adi Granth translated by Ernest Trumpp,p-72]