Thread: aik ahm hadith plz ye lazmi read karein aur dosron ko b btain

jazakAllah
when ever i heard i heard it ful
thanks for sharing

ASSALAM-O-ALAIKUM.
Respected sister or brother wateva u are, will you plez tel me from where u read it or this Hadith because on which site i was check it out it gves no result related to it.
mere pas mere ghar me bhi 3 Bukhari Sharif hain but 1 me bhi NAZHAT-UL-MAJALIS ka zikr nahi hai.
i hope ap mujhe plez btayenge k ap ne kahan search kia hai..
ALLAH HAFIZ

Originally Posted by m_yaseen

ASSALAM-O-ALAIKUM.
Respected sister or brother wateva u are, will you plez tel me from where u read it or this Hadith because on which site i was check it out it gves no result related to it.
mere pas mere ghar me bhi 3 Bukhari Sharif hain but 1 me bhi NAZHAT-UL-MAJALIS ka zikr nahi hai.
i hope ap mujhe plez btayenge k ap ne kahan search kia hai..
ALLAH HAFIZ

Yeh Hadees mustanad nahi lagti... There are some points in that Hadith that create confusion.
First of all, Base (Bunyaad) is the first, initial part of any building / city etc. By saying that Abu Bakar is the base of that city, means Abu Bakar gets the knowledge first and then it reaches to Hazoor (PBUH). Which is obviously not acceptable.. 2ndly, I have never seen any city with Roof on it...If any of you have seen such place please share with us for our knowledge...
Last but not least, As my brother Yaseen has said, there is not even a single line available in Bokhari Shareef regarding Nazhat-ul-Majalis, so proper reference is required here...

Now, if i quote the correct Hadith, for which there are thousands of books / references available even on internet is that
"Anna Madina tul Ilm wa Ali in Babuha" Mai Ilm ka Sheher hon or Ali us ka darwaza....

Hazoor ki yeh Hadees khud apna proof deti hai.. There are Millions of sayings (by Hazrat Ali) available regarding Life, God's creations, Humans, Animals, Food even on every signle topic that may come to our minds.. Whereas, if I talk abouty first three caliphs of Islam, No doubt they were Sahabas, they spreed Islam all our the world but not even a single saying is available that could proof that these personilities were gifted with Hidden Knowledge of Life (by God)

Yeh Hadees mustanad nahi lagti... There are some points in that Hadith that create confusion.
First of all, Base (Bunyaad) is the first, initial part of any building / city etc. By saying that Abu Bakar is the base of that city, means Abu Bakar gets the knowledge first and then it reaches to Hazoor (PBUH). Which is obviously not acceptable.. 2ndly, I have never seen any city with Roof on it...If any of you have seen such place please share with us for our knowledge...
Last but not least, As my brother Yaseen has said, there is not even a single line available in Bokhari Shareef regarding Nazhat-ul-Majalis, so proper reference is required here...

Now, if i quote the correct Hadith, for which there are thousands of books / references available even on internet is that
"Anna Madina tul Ilm wa Ali in Babuha" Mai Ilm ka Sheher hon or Ali us ka darwaza....

Hazoor ki yeh Hadees khud apna proof deti hai.. There are Millions of sayings (by Hazrat Ali) available regarding Life, God's creations, Humans, Animals, Food even on every signle topic that may come to our minds.. Whereas, if I talk abouty first three caliphs of Islam, No doubt they were Sahabas, they spreed Islam all our the world but not even a single saying is available that could proof that these personilities were gifted with Hidden Knowledge of Life (by God)