Thread: Recitation of Ameen Loudly Behind Imam

Fayaz Bhai, I sincerely agreed with you.
When I was a child and young adult in my country The Masjid I used to go was the "Hanafi" Ahle Sunnat Wal Jammat one, and no one was saying "Ameen" loudly after the Imaam had finished Sura Al-Fatihah.
It is here in England that any Masjid you go they say "Ameen" loudly except the Pakistani Masjid. But as travelling, distance and weather conditions prevent me from going to the Pakistani Masjid, I have to go to any local Masjid, but as I said before I say "my Ameen" quietly. (As a matter of interest I make special effort to go the Pakistani Masjid when there is Milad un Nabi).

in the all arab world they say it loudly
we should keep in the mind islam spread form makkah and madinah
how can ppl living hear make mistake i am not saying they are angels but keep in the mind this is the origin of islam ..these are the places form where islam is spread problem with us is that we follow only our murshidis don't read and don't open our mind

how can we doubt immam-e-kaba

Originally Posted by fayaz.hs

[COLOR= if he say's it loudly the will be maqroo...[/COLOR]

.how can u say this ........... what about all arab ummah u think their is maqroo may Allah subhanwataala guide me if i am wrong

Originally Posted by _knownothing_

.how can u say this ........... what about all arab ummah u think their is maqroo may Allah subhanwataala guide me if i am wrong

Sis if u r following the Hanfi way of salath then u hc to say Ameen Silently, if ur following Shafi way of salath then u say it Loudly...
I said makru to the 1 who is following Hanfi Masnath n saying Ameen Loudly...

Originally Posted by _knownothing_

in the all arab world they say it loudly
we should keep in the mind islam spread form makkah and madinah
how can ppl living hear make mistake i am not saying they are angels but keep in the mind this is the origin of islam ..these are the places form where islam is spread problem with us is that we follow only our murshidis don't read and don't open our mind

how can we doubt immam-e-kaba

Sis In Sudi dy r follwing Shafi masnath/Shafi Imaam, In this way of salth saying Ameen Loudly is allowed... If u read whole artical u can come to Know this...

Remember Imaam Azam abuhaneefa was not from Makka, but Imaam Shafi ra is from
Makka, so the Shfi musnad/style is followed in Sudi....
All 4 Imaam r RIGHT.. We hv to beleve them.

I am not dobting any 1...

Wht i hv come across is... some muslim who r following Hanfi musanth but saying Ameen Loudly, which will make Salth makru...

Originally Posted by _knownothing_

ithese are the places form where islam is spread problem with us is that we follow only our murshidis don't read and don't open our mind

Sis plz read whole artical... According to u wht u said we should not follow our Murshid, its good to read it understand it right??
Then y u r attaining classes in collage, Read the book n attain the Exams na...!!!! Correct me if am wrong.

Originally Posted by abdulmadarbux

Fayaz Bhai, I sincerely agreed with you.
When I was a child and young adult in my country The Masjid I used to go was the "Hanafi" Ahle Sunnat Wal Jammat one, and no one was saying "Ameen" loudly after the Imaan had finished Sura Al-Fatihah.
It is here in England that any Masjid you go they say "Ameen" loudly except the Pakistani Masjid. But as travelling, distance and weather condition prevent me from going to the Pakistani Masjid, I have to go to any local Masjid, but as I said before I say "my Ameen" quietly. (As a matter of interest I make special effort to go the Pakistani Masjid when there is Milad un Nabi).

Even we make small effort to do things for allah sake we will b rewarded for that... I appraciate ur effort to going long way to Pak Masjid for ... Bhai....

Originally Posted by fayaz.hs

Sis plz read whole artical... According to u wht u said we should not follow our Murshid, its good to read it understand it right??
Then y u r attaining classes in collage, Read the book n attain the Exams na...!!!! Correct me if am wrong.

yes are right is this case
but there are ppl who follow dem blindly which is wrong

i agree with fyaz bro if one if follower of one of four Imaams then he has to follow it completely and not to follow others. bcoz there are many matters on that hanfi and shia scholars have diffrent teachings. as in Hanfi madhab hadrat imaam abu Hanifa has told us not to do Sajda at the time of zawaal and should not offer asar prayer before 20 or 15 minutes of complt sunset while in other madhabs or schools of thought they have allowed doing sajdah at any time and there is no time compultion for sajdah.(especilaay after reciting sajdah ayat in Quraan)
Imaam abu hanifa has forbidden it bcoz its time of worship of ppl belonging to other religions especially idol and sun worshippers. so its better for muslims to not mix with their timings.
i gave such example just to explain why we should only follow one Imaam completely.